Appraisals

Our expert team provides services to clients looking to either divest or procure exquisite things of value. Working from our Bowling Green, Kentucky office, we ensure each item is properly identified, it’s condition assessed, and it’s value estimated – based on average market sales from auctions, retail, and wholesale sources.

Downsizing

With over 40 years of combined experience in estate services, we have assembled a number of partners in Bowling Green and the surrounding area to assist with all of your asset needs. We start with an assessment and break down the estate or collection into groupings of assets and identify where they will perform best, and yield the highest return. Whether that be an auction house, an estate \ tag sale, or a national broker. We perform this based on your needs and timing, as we have found that everyone has different needs and motivations.

Curation

Often times, provenance or certification of an item is needed to optimize it’s value, or to provide confidence during an acquisition. Our partnerships across the US allow us to know who to contact and what kind of certification matters, ensuring our clients get the best value and that our reputation remains spotless.

Specialties

As with any industry, specialization is important. At Tuttle & Company, while we work with any client on their needs – our specialties include – Fine Art, Victorian and Edwardian period items, Firearms, Swords, Militaria, Fine jewelry (including watches), and Early Americana.

Tonja Tuttle

Creative Director

Eric Tuttle

Executive Curator

Holly M. Beauchamp

Curator

Matthew Tuttle

Curator

Years of Expertise & Professionalism

Expertly connecting customers around the world, and right here in Bowling Green Ky. with the perfect item to suit their unique needs. The challenge with living in a small town is finding someone you can trust to assist with the purchase or sale of that unique item.

Our commitment to excellence, robust network of partners, and innovative combination of digital platforms ensures an unparalleled experience.

Tuttle & Company can get you up to 3X more than other local businesses, we are not a pawn broker, or a metals shop. We look beyond the weight or composition of your valuables.

Our Ratings – as of March 2025:

Testimonials

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Average Rating: 5.0 (based on 2500 reviews)

Among eBay “Top Rated” companies

eBay rated as “Above Standard”

Excellent

GE radio arrived safe and sound today, item was just as described, well packaged. I am very pleased with the seller, would definitely buy from again. I would recommend him to anyone. A+A+A+.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

eBay – Patvale45

Smooth Process

Quick shipping, I think it was two days and my leather pants were at my door! Packaging was good, nothing special. Perfect fit, new, as discarded. Value was great! Thanks for everything! Highly recommend!

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

eBay – Bwat81

Great Experience

Item arrived on time and as described. Box was positively chock-full of packing peanuts so the item arrived very safely. Beautiful tool and piece of history for the asking price! I heartily recommend this seller!

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

eBay – GentlestofGiants

Highly Recommend

A great place to shop for rare and hard to find items. Delivered fast, packaged well and at a great price. 100% satisfied with product and store service. “Tuttle&Company” is 5 Star A++++++. Will shop here again.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

eBay – Smal1320